[Bigbrownie]

Alight here is the first part of the sonic adventure 2 battle cutscene project. I hope you enjoy. And this is my first huge project so let me know what you think.

YouTube - Sonic Adventure 2 cutscene dubbing Part...

Cast:
Sonic: JohnnyIO
Tails: r2ninjaturtle
Knuckles: Rising-chud
Amy: Sonichearts
Shadow: Vacuus
Eggman: TrueBlue
Rouge: ryugexu

Maria: sangovengence
GUN: Tinkerjet(Aeroplane speaker), LG65(Aeroplane Radio), ericJmonkey (Gun solider from shadow scene)
GUN base annoucer: CanisSkye

[SonicShadows]

Wow, the voicing for that was really similar to the original cast. JohnnyIO is a good Sonic, although I think he could deliver a bit better. Rising-chud was probably my favorite, and I think he is one of the best Knuckles I've heard in a while. I also really liked TrueBlue's Eggman, and I tip my hat to his 'Oh-ho!'. Ryugexu was a unique voice, and not a copy of the original, so I enjoyed listening to her take on Rouge. Sangovengence's voice fit really well for Maria, and although it sounded similar to the original, it had its own awesomeness. And last but not least, Vacuus was a totally awesome Shadow. I did feel like there were some moments where his voice didn't fit in, but overall he delivered very well. The mixing was a little sketchy for my tastes, but it was better than nothing in the background. I really enjoyed watching this and I look forward to Part 2.

[Bigbrownie]

Thanks sonicshadows. I mean for my first project i think i did quite well. But ill try and do better for part 2

[LG65]

Oh... the memories playing this game! For the occasion, I decided to watch the level clears. Here's my critique of everyone!

Sonic the Hedgehog: JohnnyIo

I critiqued you before in the trailer piece, but I'll quote what I said:

I think you have a nice balance between Ryan & Jason... again, a GOOD thing! (and I don't mean to sound biased, but I don't like Griffith as Sonic) Keep it coming, man!

Knuckles the Echidna: Rising-chud

I enjoyed hearing you, man! You really brought out Knux's personality and flair, like Scott Drier did! Well done.

Shadow the Hedgehog: Vacuus

Very impressive! Like JohnnyIo to Ryan & Jason's Sonic, you have balance between David Humphrey's & Jason Griffith's Shadow. I really love your performance so far.

Dr. Eggman: True_Blue

Balance is key, and I thought you impressed me with a balance of both Mike Pollock & Deem Bistrow (the latter R.I.P.). Keep it coming!

Rouge the Bat: ryugexu

Well done here! Lani Minella remains my favourite pro VA for Rouge... and I thought you did beautifully on par with her! You executed well, personality and voice-wise! Well done!

Maria Robotnik: sangovengence

Pretty good, but... I was thinking that Maria is a little on the softer side. Other than that, fantastic.

So ends those with names, now with us, the Guardian Unit of Nations (G.U.N.)!

Airplane Pilot: Tinker_Jet

Quoting from the previous critique:

Supremely lovely! A nice change-up from the original version, which is a GOOD thing!

Airplane Radio: LG65 (Me!)

Quoting from the previous critique:

I can honestly say I sound like the original VA in the actual game. But... my last line... sucked. I just didn't put enough heart into that one.

Soldier (in ARK): ericJmonkey

Nice one-liner! That's all I have to say.

Base Announcer: CanisSkye

Very well done! Again, I have nothing more to say.

Mixing:

I agree with everyone here on the whole SFX & BGM thing. Let me drop in quote from my critique in the trailer:

Me & Tinker_Jet sound muffled over the sound effects and music. I think maybe... that you probably need to balance out the volume of the two. And... I think I could have added a nice 'radio' effect for my voice.

I also noticed that Shadow's voice got covered by the SFX at spots. Not good... You might want to initiate some balance of volume.

But, bottom-line, balance of volume is key. Good job, Bigbrownie!

[Sh3rl0ck]

I really enjoyed watching this! It was awesome! So here is some critique!

Sonic: JohnnyIO
You are the perfect Sonic the Hegdehog! Your a mix of Ryan Drummond and Jason Griffith! And thats what made your performance so well! Great Job!

Knuckles: Risen-Chud
I LOVE YOUR KNUCKLES VOICE!!! It's undescribably awesome! You really got into Knuckles Character! Great Work! ^^

Shadow: Vacuus
You make a really good Shadow! You sound so much like David Humphrey! You were a bit to quiet at times...which made it really hard to hear, but that can be worked on! Over all Good Job!

Dr. Eggman: TrueBlue
Best Unofficial Eggman 'EVER'! Enough said.

Rouge: ryugexu
I really liked listening to you! Your voice is different from both the original and the 4kids version! You gave a different side to Rouge, which made it even more interesting! Good Job on the voice!~

Can't wait to see part two! ^^

[True_Blue]

I'm sorry I took so long to critique!

Sonic: JohnnyIO - Like I said last time, I needed to hear more of you. I'm convinced, you make a good Sonic.

Knuckles: Rising-chud - I have no complaints here, you sound good for Knux. Keep it up!

Shadow: Vacuus - Dark and mysterious, but I couldn't hear some of your voice due to the mixing problems (sorry brownie). I need to hear more of you, but so far so good.

Eggman: TrueBlue - I think my Eggman turned out okay.

Rouge: ryugexu - You're great as Rouge, right up there with Lani Manella. I thought she could've sounded a little more angry when she started shaking Knuckles for breaking the emerald. Thank goodness you don't sound like the horrible 4Kids VA.

Maria: sangovengence - You make a good Maria, but when you spoke it sounded like she wasn't hurt. I'd like to hear more, though.

GUN: Tinkerjet(Aeroplane speaker) - Nice and calm in the beginning and then the panic kicked in. You did good.

LG65(Aeroplane Radio) - You started good in the beginning, but you sounded more calm than panicked in the later lines. Just work on that and you'll be good.

ericJmonkey (Gun solider from shadow scene) - Every line matters, and you did good with the one-liner.

GUN base annoucer: CanisSkye - Well done with the whole Intruder Alert voice. Nice and calm, although I though she could've sounded a little louder.

TV reporter: ??? - I didn't see who was credited for this, but the voice sounded as good as the voice they used in the dub version.

Mixing: BigBrownie - Everyone else has already pointed out what needs to be worked on, so I've got nothing to add. Good first try on this, I know video and audio mixing can be a bitch. Looking forward to seeing the rest!