PDA

View Full Version : Real human bodies on display


..Humanoid.Typhoon..
07-07-2004, 10:41 PM
My friend sent this to me. I was umm, relatively disturbed I admit, but maybe I'm just that way, I dunno. It just kinda, irked me wrong. ^^;; *shudders* I can't explain it, and I was curious if it was just me...

What do you all think?
Do you think this is alright to do?
Would you ever go to see this exhibit?
Would you ever volunteer yourself for it?

Human body exposed in new exhibit
Friday, July 2, 2004 Posted: 10:58 AM EDT (1458 GMT)

http://i.a.cnn.net/cnn/2004/US/West/07/02/body.exhibit.ap/story.vert.body.world.ap.jpg
(Three cadavers are displayed with their blood vessels visible in the "Body Worlds" exhibit.)

LOS ANGELES, California (AP) -- A pregnant woman lies on her side with a hand behind her head as if posing for a nude photograph. But her dead body isn't the only thing exposed. Her heart, intestines and 8-month-old fetus are visible as well.

The woman was one of more than 200 people who donated their cadavers for use in "Body Worlds: The Anatomical Exhibition of Real Human Bodies," which makes its U.S. debut Friday at the California Science Center.

Intended to teach people about human skeletal, cardiovascular and other systems, the final exhibit includes 25 bodies that have undergone a process called "plastination" in which body fluids are replaced with clear, pliable plastic.

Most have been skinned or dissected to reveal muscles, bones, nerves and organs. Some show damage done by illnesses such as cancer and lung disease.

Since debuting in Tokyo in 1996, the show has aroused controversy as well as curiosity.

Its shocking display of flesh and bones has offended many observers who claim it violates the sanctity of the human body.

However, German scientist Gunther von Hagens, who created the exhibit and the preservation technique, defends his work as educational and enlightening.

"It's more than time that we show how the body really looks," he said.

In the past eight years, "Body Worlds" has toured Asia and Europe, attracting nearly 15 million visitors and a number of critics who have dubbed von Hagens "Dr. Death" and "Frankenstein" because of his work.

In Frankfurt, Germany, the Lutheran church said the display was amoral and insulting to the dead. At a London show, one visitor covered the body of the pregnant woman with a blanket because he couldn't stand seeing the fetus.

During exhibit stops, about 6,000 people signed papers donating their bodies to von Hagens' institute for possible plastination. Most hope to further medical science, he said.

"The limited possibilities -- to be either burned or to rot in earth -- always seemed degrading to me and were problematic," wrote one female donor whose identity was withheld. "It is a good thing that Professor von Hagens went beyond these limited possibilities."

Recent visitors to the California Science Center said they had mixed feelings about the coming exhibit.

Eva Edwards was fascinated until she discovered the exhibit featured real human bodies. She quickly saw a conflict between her religious and scientific beliefs.

"Religiously, we feel the body should be respected and buried," she said. "I don't really feel that scientifically."

The effect on her 9-year-old daughter was even more profound. The girl started crying when she realized the bodies in the preview pictures were real.

The body parts didn't bother 16-year-old Zahra Nankani, who was visiting the center as part of a youth conference on medicine.

"I think it's amazing to see real live body parts, and the vulnerability and intricacy of a human body," Nankani said. "Most people don't get to see this."

Visitors younger than 13 won't be permitted to see "Body Worlds" without a parent or guardian.

Jeffrey N. Rudolph, president of the California Science Center, said the exhibit underwent a rigorous review by religious leaders, medical professionals and bioethicists before it was brought to Los Angeles.

He said the panel knew it would make people uncomfortable but decided the educational value outweighed any possible controversy.

"It's not an ethical issue," Rudolph said. "It's more of a visceral reaction."

http://www.cnn.com/2004/US/West/07/02/body.exhibit.ap/index.html

Crimson
07-08-2004, 02:39 AM
I think that is cool.

I can see why some people would easily be disturbed by it, but I wouldn't call it wrong considering that all the people *chose* to be in the project after their death.

Katie
07-08-2004, 02:48 AM
Weeeeeeird. That photograph doesn't look real... but that's probably because it isn't. They said that they replaced fluids with plastic, so that's just a bunch of red tubes.

I would never want people to stare at my dead, skinless body. Eww. Violation. But I believe in respecting the wishes of the dead, and hell, if those people wanted their cadavers on display, who is to say they shouldn't be?

Ashley Keen
07-08-2004, 01:45 PM
If they're consenting adults...

But still not an exhibit I would go to see.

thunderstormgenesis
07-09-2004, 12:50 AM
ooooookay......*goes bac to furuba party, heavily disturbed*

..Humanoid.Typhoon..
07-09-2004, 05:23 AM
ooooookay......*goes bac to furuba party, heavily disturbed*

Ahh, sorry about that... ;_; I'll join you at the party.
*Runs away from her own thread*

danyata
07-09-2004, 07:08 PM
I have no problem with it. I may even go see the exhibit one day :) I find the human body fascinating, and as long as these people have consenting to having their bodies displayed, then sure, fine by moi. I'm not disturbed, but I think being at the exhibit would be a lot different to seeing photos.

Ahhh the wonders of sciene.

Yami no Kitsune
07-10-2004, 03:21 AM
Yup, I'm all for it... its not like the people are using their bodies anymore, they are elsewhere. And the people wanted their bodies to be used for educational purposes. I don't see what all the fuss is all about. Med students see cadavers all the time.

I am also fascinated by the human body and I think that people should go see the exhibit. I probaby will if I get the chance. ^_^

Henageshi
07-10-2004, 03:37 AM
I don't see anything wrong with it. It's not like the people there can actually do anything about it cuz well....they're dead. o_O

But like chibikat says, I really do want to respect the dead too but that doesn't mean we can't experiment on them to learn more about it.